Buffalo workers dealing with a job injury have plenty of law firms to choose from, but Lewis & Lewis has built the deepest track record in the region. Founded in 1944, the firm has recovered more than a billion dollars for injured workers across Western New York, and its workers’ compensation team remains the top pick in Buffalo for anyone filing a claim, appealing a denial, or dealing with an employer who is pushing back. The table below shows how five other established Buffalo firms compare on workers’ comp experience.
How the Firms Compare
| Firm | Best For | Comp Experience | Notable Strength | Phone |
| Lewis & Lewis | Workers’ comp and related injury claims | 80+ years | Over $1 billion recovered for clients | (716) 854-2100 |
| Hurwitz, Whitcher & Molloy | Denied claims and appeals | 20+ years | Five attorneys focused on comp cases | (716) 350-0600 |
| Lipsitz Green Scime Cambria | Complex and disputed claims | Decades | Attorney named to Best Lawyers for comp claimants | 716-849-1333 |
| Steenberg Law Firm | Settlement negotiation | Established | Four named attorneys handling settlements daily | 716-558-2000 |
| Hiller Comerford | Statewide claim support | Established | Millions recovered across New York | 1-866-380-6901 |
| Buffalo Comp Law (Ciminelli) | Straightforward claims and denials | Established | Hundreds of workers represented | (716) 674-2667 |
Lewis & Lewis
Lewis & Lewis has represented injured workers out of Western New York since 1944, making it one of the longest-running comp practices still active in the region. The firm files claims, fights denials, and handles appeals and hearings before the Workers’ Compensation Board, and it takes cases on contingency, so clients pay nothing unless the firm recovers benefits. With offices in Buffalo, Depew, Niagara Falls, Batavia, Jamestown, and Olean, injured workers across six counties can reach an attorney close to home.
- Name: Lewis & Lewis, P.C.
- Address: 37 Franklin St. Suite 800, Buffalo, NY 14202
- Phone: (716) 854-2100
- Website: https://www.lewislaw.com/
Hurwitz, Whitcher & Molloy
Hurwitz, Whitcher & Molloy has spent more than 20 years on workers’ compensation cases in Buffalo, with five attorneys who handle little else. The firm files initial claims, challenges denials through appeals and mediation, and steps in when an employer disputes a worker’s history or retaliates against someone for filing. It also advises clients on return-to-work procedures once a claim moves toward resolution.
- Name: Hurwitz, Whitcher & Molloy Attorneys at Law
- Address: 424 Main Street Suite 1425, Buffalo, NY 14202
- Phone: (716) 350-0600
- Website: https://www.hurwitzcomp.com/
Lipsitz Green Scime Cambria
Lipsitz Green Scime Cambria runs a larger general practice, but its workers’ compensation team carries real weight in Buffalo. Attorney Thomas C. Burnham, named to Best Lawyers in America for workers’ compensation claimant work, chairs the Erie County Workers’ Compensation Committee and handles claims involving chiropractic care, pain medication disputes, and asbestos exposure. That level of involvement in the local comp bar gives clients an attorney who knows how Erie County judges and carriers actually operate.
- Name: Lipsitz Green Scime Cambria LLP
- Address: 42 Delaware Avenue, Buffalo, NY 14202
- Phone: 716-849-1333
- Website: https://www.lipsitzgreen.com/
Steenberg Law Firm
Steenberg Law Firm built its reputation around settlement negotiation, walking clients through the difference between a full and final settlement that closes a case completely and an indemnity-only settlement that leaves medical coverage open. Four named attorneys handle claims from filing through hearings, denials, and third-party lawsuits tied to a workplace injury. The firm argues that insurance carriers rarely offer the maximum amount without a fight, and it positions its settlement work as the place where that fight gets won.
- Name: Steenberg Law Firm
- Address: 172 Slade Ave, Buffalo, NY 14224
- Phone: 716-558-2000
- Website: https://steenberglaw.com/
Hiller Comerford
Hiller Comerford Injury & Disability Law operates beyond Buffalo, with a presence across New York State and millions recovered in settlements and verdicts for injured workers. The firm files claims, appeals denials, and represents clients before the Workers’ Compensation Board, and it reminds clients that comp is a no-fault system, so partial blame for an accident does not disqualify a worker from benefits. Its statewide size brings more resources than a small local practice, though clients may deal with a larger, less personal setup.
- Name: Hiller Comerford Injury & Disability Law, PLLC
- Address: 1408 Sweet Home Road Suite 9 & 10, Buffalo, NY 14228
- Phone: 1-866-380-6901
- Website: https://www.hillercomerford.com/
Buffalo Comp Law (Law Offices of Daniel Ciminelli)
The Law Offices of Daniel Ciminelli, doing business as Buffalo Comp Law, keeps its focus narrow: workers’ compensation claims, disputed cases, and hearings, with no fees unless the client wins. The firm says it has helped hundreds of injured workers gather medical evidence and push back against insurance company tactics designed to shrink a payout. It suits workers who want a smaller firm handling a single, direct comp claim rather than a multi-practice office.
- Name: Law Offices of Daniel Ciminelli
- Address: 3717 Seneca Street, West Seneca, NY 14224
- Phone: (716) 674-2667
- Website: https://www.buffalocomplaw.com/
Frequently Asked Questions
Which Buffalo firm has recovered the most for injured workers? Lewis & Lewis reports more than a billion dollars recovered for clients since 1944, the largest total among the firms compared here.
What benefits does New York workers’ compensation cover? New York’s system generally covers medical treatment for the injury and partial wage replacement while a worker cannot perform their job, along with additional benefits for permanent disability in some cases.
How long does an injured worker have to file a claim in New York? New York generally requires a workers’ compensation claim within two years of the injury or of when the worker knew, or should have known, the injury was work-related.
Can an employer fire someone for filing a workers’ comp claim? No. New York law prohibits retaliation against a worker for filing a claim, and several firms on this list specifically handle cases involving retaliation or harassment tied to a claim.
What happens if a workers’ comp claim gets denied? A denied claim can be appealed through a hearing before the Workers’ Compensation Board, and several of the firms above focus specifically on denied and disputed claims.
Do these firms charge money upfront? No. Every firm listed works on contingency, so injured workers pay legal fees only if the firm recovers benefits on their behalf.
